Pie Baker Recipes for the Holidays and Beyond

Posted by

No holiday celebration is complete without at least a couple of delicious pies. Am I right? Since this year is so much different than most, I want to make sure that we can make the holidays as traditional and as delicious as possible. This means that I will definitely be breaking out my sassafras superstone® stoneware pie baker and baking some delicious holiday goodies. This is also the reason why I have put together this list of pie baker recipes for the holidays and beyond to share with all of you so that you can enjoy baking some delicious desserts too!

This delicious list of recipes will keep your taste buds happy this holiday season. If you are unable to celebrate the holidays with your family and friends this year, these pie baker recipes also make great food gifts in case you feel like doing a porch gift drop off!

Pie Baker Recipes for the Holidays and Beyond

You are going to love these pie baker recipes so much that you might find yourself in need of a second (or third or fourth) pie baker to keep you baking without any slow down!

Purple Sweet Potato Cheesecake

Well, I never said that these would all be traditional recipes! If you love cheesecake, but want to make a splash and show off your unique side, thispurple sweet potato cheesecake is exactly what you need!

Caramel Apple Cheesecake

If you want to have a beautiful dessert to serve, but don’t necessarily have the time or desire to bake, this Caramel Apple Cheesecake is just the thing for you. Be sure to prepare it in advance though, because it does require 12 hours to set.

Cherry Pie with Homemade Pie

I am not a fan of cherry pie myself, but it does happen to be my husband’s favorite pie flavor, so I always make at least one cherry pie recipe during the holidays. This Cherry Pie with Homemade Pie filling has been a huge hit!

Classic Apple Pie

Does it get any more traditional than a Classic Apple Pie recipe for the holidays? I think there is some sort of unspoken rule out there that says that you have to have apple pie on your holiday dessert table, right?

Crustless Pumpkin Pie with Topping

Another classic recipe that just has to be on your holiday dessert table is a pumpkin pie. That being said, no one says your pumpkin pie has to be like all the others. When you think of a Crustless Pumpkin Pie, you probably aren’t thinking about a Crustless Pumpkin Pie with Streusel Topping. You should be though, because it is surprisingly delicious!

Secretly Vegan Chocolate Pecan Pie

If you, or someone you are cooking for this holiday season is vegan, this Secretly Vegan Chocolate Pecan Pie is a must for your holiday baking list.

Pecan Cheesecake Pie

If you are struggling to decide whether you want a classic pecan pie or a rich cheesecake, no worries. You can make this Pecan Cheesecake Pie and have a little bit of both in one delicious dessert!

Easy Apple Pie

Another delicious, yet Easy Apple Pie recipe for the holidays. I don’t know about yours, but our family seems to love having several different types of apple pie at the holiday table each and every year, so I always make at least 2 different apple pie recipes. It may seem silly, but everyone seems to love having the diverse selection.

Pumpkin Biscoff Pecan Pie

Now this is a unique spin on a classic pie, but trust me, it is delicious! This Pumpkin Biscoff Pecan Pie has a flaky crust, a creamy pumpkin/cookie butter filling and is topped with chewy pecans. Can you say rich?! I’m excited for you to try this one if you haven’t already.


Tip: Use the Right Bakeware for Your Pie Baker Recipes

We talk about this often, but there is no substitute for the right bakeware for your pie baker recipes. The right bakeware like the sassafras superstone® stoneware pie baker heats evenly which produces a flaky, light crust that will create that melt-in-your mouth taste that you love about your favorite pies.

Our glazed sassafras superstone® stoneware pie bakers comes in 4 color options with an unglazed exterior.

Serve it up

If you need accessories for cutting and serving your pies, look no further–– Sassafras® has a wood-handled spatula and a silicone-handled spatula for all your baking needs.


We at Sassafras® hope you find these recipes and tips helpful and that that you have a festive holiday season!